Sunday, February 13, 2011

QQC: Chapter 0

Sorry, I didn't realize there was actually a previous reading due here...
Quote: (see left)

Question: The Julian Calendar did not have the zero issue associated with it because of its dating origins. What year, on the Julian calendar, was the Gregorian calender adopted?

Comment: I thought that it was weird to think about the fact that there is no year zero. Of course, as the book mentions, zero is not usually used as a counting number, and just as the years go from 1 B.C to 1 AD, so, too, do the centuries jump from the first century B.C. to the first century AD, which, of course has a zero in the hundreds, or "centuries" position. However, as strange as the mix-up between B.C. and AD is, the fact remains that, had the Pope decided to include a year zero, the concept, even with the knowledge of the logic behind it, would be stranger still. I suppose that, no matter which way we turn, we will be stuck in this matter.

Another part I found interesting about the reading is how late in the game the concept and notion of zero comes into play. This is 1582. Shakespeare is on the up and up, the Ottoman are rising to power just a few years after conquering the Byzantines, and the Renaissance in Europe has already started. And zero is still [insert zero equivalent expression here], nowhere to be seen. Such a strange thought that Shakespeare, though granted the knowledge of zero as a number and a concept and as a digit used to hold place value, did not understand it in the same way that we do today.

Friday, February 11, 2011

Chapter nano

Quote: (see right)-->

Question: Does a [modern] calculator operate on the same basic principle as an abacus?


Comment: I thought that the idea of Romans using binary to solve math problems is pretty cool, especially when binary seems like such a modern invention in terms of ways to think about and express numbers. Especially when you consider the thought that advanced abacus users could utilize the simplicity of the binary-based abacus to do incredibly quick mental calculations. I also thought it interesting to note that calculus, the name of this class, comes from calculus ponere. Ponere means "to put" (in Spanish, it is poner), so our Calculus class is really just about pebbles (OK, so not really, but you get the idea behind this comment). Sometimes our origins are not as flattering as they ought to be....

Friday, January 28, 2011

Gauss QQC

Quote:

In his Disquisitiones Gauss also created the modern rigorous approach to mathematics. He had become impatient with the loose writing and sloppy proofs of his predecessors, and resolved that his own works would be beyond criticism in this respect. As he wrote to a friend, 'I mean the word proof not in the sense of the lawyers, who set two half-proofs equal to a whole one, but in the sense of the mathematician where 1/2 proof=0
and it is demanded for proof that every doubt becomes impossible.' The Disquisitiones is composed in this spirit and in Gauss's mature style, which is terse, rigid, devoid of motivation, and in many places so carefully polished that it is almost unintelligible.

Question:
It does seem a waste to have a work so polished that it is not easy to understand, especially when you are writing for your work to be read and understood by others (unlike Newton, who purposefully wrote in a difficult style). Why would anyone spend hours and hours of their time to be as terse as possible, especially when it is not required that one be extremely terse?

Comment: I thought that it was interesting to read about Gauss, and how he was such a brilliant mathematician. One wonders though, how when one can be so brilliant, and yet fail to let the public be aware of your ideas, how ultimately brilliant you are.... His feat at age three of spotting a mistake in the bookkeeping is definitely the mark of an extremely smart and intelligent person. I especially like his point of how, in math, 1/2 proof + 1/2 proof = 0, or simply does not equal anything of meaning, which makes especially clear the importance of having a well-grounded math foundation and understanding that all the steps are necessary when solving a problem.

Friday, January 21, 2011

Euler QQC

Quote: "It was through his work that the symbols e, π, and i (=sqrt(-1)) became common currency for all mathematicians, and it was he who linked them together in the astonishing relation e^(πi) = -1. This is merely a special case (put θ=π) of his famous formula e^(i θ) = cosθ+ i sinθ, which connects the exponential and trigonometric functions and is absolutely indispensable in higher analysis. Among his other contributions to standard mathematical notation were sin x, cos x, the use of f(x) for an unspecified function, and the use of Σ for summation....
Question: Is there anything that Euler didn't do? (other than not discover calculus)
Comment: I think that this is pretty amazing, the type of formulas and notations that he impressed upon the world of mathematics. Since we all use these notations in math class, I think Euler is a pretty relevant person. I was especially surprised by the fact that e raised to the power of i times pi equals -1, since this seems to defy the logic of an imaginary number. I don't know what the specific ramifications of this equation are, but they seem to suggest that i is a number that has a comprehensible value (other than sqrt(-1)). All this and 13 children, too! I am surprised that anybody could get anything done with 13 kids running around, even if they were very-well behaved. I was a little disappointed, however, when I read that the bridges of Konigsberg problem really was unsolvable.

Wednesday, January 5, 2011

Liebniz

Quote: (Whoa, no image this time. Could this be an actual one line quote?!)All this, in an age when even the most intelligent and well-educated people considered Genesis to be the final authority in such matters [as pertaining to the subject of the origin of the world and life].

Question: Since when does well-educated and intelligent have anything to do with understanding Genesis as the authority on the human condition and origin? That is, is viewing Genesis as an end all authority on the matter make one ill-educated and a moron? This is certainly what the article seems to say.

Comment: I don't really see how one could consider someone that understands Genesis as the authority on the matter of the origin of the world and the universe as thick. Tell that to all the scientists and physicists and biologists that believe that Genesis is the end-all authority. Certainly Leibniz's ideas are pretty standard and in-line with the prevailing modern thought today. Certainly his understanding of how the earth formed could be 100% right. It just remains that his and modern science's understanding of how the earth got here in the first place is not necessarily being viewed in the right light. It is certainly possible for the earth to have formed exactly as Leibniz described (not that I agree with him, but we'll go with it for now). Perhaps not probably in point of view, but definitely possible. What the real objection here is, of course, is that the idea that to be a modern thinker and to be labeled as smart, intelligent, well-educated, and high-minded one has to believe in evolution, or at least the deist understanding of the universe, is a rather limited viewpoint. I feel rather upset, considering the fact that those that do feel that Genesis answers a considerable number of questions that evolutionary biology, universal geological study, and philosophical metaphysics (based on these evolutionary terms) cannot, nor will ever answer. Genesis might not answer all questions, but it certainly answers all the questions that we need to know the answers to. Needless to say, I mean not to offend, but I don't go around calling Darwinists that believe that evolution answers all questions about life, the universe, and everything moronic blockheads, or at least half-wits, which is, again, certainly what the above quote suggests.

Thursday, November 18, 2010

QQC: Bryson Chapters 5 & 6

Quote: See left

Question: The question is, what sophisticated dating techniques do we have today (besides the leather jacket and sports car) that allow us to more accurately measure the dates beyond 200 million years? How much more of an idea do we have today of these ages when all of our modern conclusions are based on observational data (and, by the way, how do you observe 65 million years?)?

Comment: This is an interesting quote, considering that, for the most part, our dating techniques are based largely on radiometric dating, which is limited by our assumptions about the previous nature of the earth, and how it was formed. We assume certain factors and constants, based on what little observational data we have of 4.5 billion years ago. While after assuming the constants, the rest is pure and very certain math, there are assumptions made about the current status of the Earth, and whether of not it was necessary for these elements to be present at or during the construction phase of the solar system. To be more precise, we are assuming, based on our observational data, that not only does it take 4.5 billion years for U-238 (uranium) to decay into Pb-206 (lead), but that, based on what else we find in our samples (alpha particles, etc.), there had to be a specific amount of uranium present in the earth at formation time for the information to be correct. Most rocks on earth started out with (relatively) lots of uranium, and now rocks that have lead and helium and a little itty bit of uranium left in them must have had a certain amount of only uranium at the beginning of their decay cycle, which would have began with the formation of the solar system and earth. But what stops the uranium from beginning its decay before the formation of the solar system, since the solar system did not create the uranium? (Usually Stars, not planetary nebulae accretion disks, create new molecules via gravity and radiation) And who's to say that the lead and helium weren't already in the rock when the earth was formed, or that the rock didn't coalesce and include little bits of hydrogen and helium in its formation, considering that there was enough helium and hydrogen around to make a star that could burn for over 10 billion+ years (almost the accepted age of the universe, which is 13.7 bil.)? We might want to consider just what exactly the accurate as described in reference to these dating methods is based upon (and remember, the math itself is good).

Friday, November 5, 2010

QQC: Bryson; The Measure of Things


My QQCs seem to keep getting shorter and shorter...

Quote: See Right (for once)
Question: It is incredible to think of the discoveries that Cavendish made without feeling the need to tell anyone about them. I wonder if he made any other discoveries that no one still knows about... Also, how much are things on Earth affected by the Sun's gravity, considering that it holds everything in place up to over one light-year (5.87 trillion miles) away? Doesn't it have a slight affect on us on earth, or does the distance factor so exceed it's gravity that Earth is infinitely more attractive
Comment: I think that it's amazing that he made discoveries that, for the rest of the world, weren't made until the 19th century. I thought that it was interesting to note that when he measured the gravitational constant, that his value of 6 sextillion tonnes (that's a six followed by 21 zeros) for the weight (mass) of the earth has not really been improved upon, it was so accurate. That Mitchell, though, could have even thought of anything such as a machine to measure the gravitational constant is absolutely incredible, considering the actual values that he was considering measuring (the constant is something like 6x10^-6 or so, incredibly small).